DEV Community

Amit Kayal for AWS Community Builders

Posted on Edited on

Do We Really Need Multiple Layers in Our Observability Architecture?

Do We Really Need Multiple Layers in Our Observability Architecture?

Fluent Bit vs Grafana Alloy vs OpenTelemetry Collector vs AWS Firehose — An Engineering Leadership Perspective

One thing I have learned over the years is that adding technology to an architecture is easy. Justifying why we need it is much harder.

I was recently evaluating Fluent Bit, Grafana Alloy, OpenTelemetry Collector, and AWS Kinesis Firehose (now Amazon Data Firehose) for an observability architecture.

It raised a simple question: Are we solving a real engineering problem, or are we adding more components than we actually need?

Why do we need Firehose if Fluent Bit can do the job?

Consider a typical logging pipeline.

Fluent Bit collects logs from applications, parses and transforms them, buffers records in memory or on disk, and delivers them to destinations such as S3, OpenSearch, or Loki.

It can handle most of the pipeline without requiring another service.

So why introduce AWS Firehose?

Firehose offers managed buffering, delivery retries, and integration with AWS services. These are useful capabilities, particularly when we do not want to own the downstream delivery infrastructure.

But if Fluent Bit already meets our requirements, adding Firehose means another service, additional cost, and another dependency.

I would not introduce Firehose just for buffering or transformation. I would introduce it when its managed delivery capabilities provide a clear operational benefit.

What about Grafana Alloy and OpenTelemetry Collector?

This is where the discussion gets more interesting.

Fluent Bit is primarily designed for efficient log collection and forwarding. It is lightweight, performs well in container environments, and works well when logging is our main requirement.

Grafana Alloy takes a broader approach. It supports logs, metrics, traces, and profiling, making it attractive for organizations building a unified observability platform, particularly around the Grafana ecosystem.

OpenTelemetry Collector also supports logs, metrics, and traces, with a stronger emphasis on open standards and vendor-neutral telemetry pipelines.

Alloy itself builds on the OpenTelemetry Collector ecosystem, so they share several underlying capabilities.

The key difference is not simply what each technology supports, but where it fits into our engineering strategy.

Consideration Fluent Bit Grafana Alloy OTel Collector AWS Firehose
Primary focus Log processing Unified observability Vendor-neutral telemetry Managed data delivery
Logs Strong Strong Strong Delivery-focused
Metrics and traces Supported Strong Strong Not a general collector
Transformation Yes Yes Yes Yes, with supported mechanisms
Buffering Memory and filesystem Component-dependent Memory and optional persistent queues Managed buffering
Infrastructure ownership Self-managed Self-managed Self-managed AWS-managed
Cloud flexibility High High High AWS-specific

I would not select a tool based on the number of features it supports. I would select it based on the problem we're trying to solve and the operational responsibility we're willing to own.

Buffering does not automatically mean reliability

This is one area I would examine closely before making a production decision.

All four technologies provide buffering capabilities, but their failure recovery characteristics differ.

What happens when a Kubernetes node crashes? What happens when the destination is unavailable for several hours? What happens when log volume suddenly increases tenfold?

Fluent Bit supports filesystem buffering, but that doesn't automatically protect us against node or storage failure.

OpenTelemetry Collector can use persistent queues, while Grafana Alloy offers buffering and persistence mechanisms depending on the components being used.

Firehose provides managed buffering and retries, but it is not a replacement for a durable, replayable streaming platform such as Kafka or Kinesis Data Streams.

Before selecting any of them, I would want clarity on our acceptable data loss, recovery expectations, and retention requirements.

For application debugging logs, occasional loss during exceptional failures may be acceptable. For audit or compliance data, it may not be.

Reliability should be defined by our requirements, not by a checkbox in a product comparison.

The real cost is not just infrastructure

We often compare open-source and managed services purely on pricing.

But running Fluent Bit, Alloy, or OpenTelemetry Collector also means managing deployments, configurations, upgrades, monitoring, and failures.

Firehose reduces some of that responsibility, but introduces usage-based costs and AWS dependency.

The right comparison is total cost of ownership.

If we already have a mature Kubernetes platform, operating Fluent Bit might add very little overhead.

If we are a smaller team heavily invested in AWS, managed delivery could be worth paying for.

I would also question whether we are collecting and retaining more telemetry than we need. Reducing unnecessary logs can sometimes save more money than changing the collector.

What would I choose?

My approach would be relatively straightforward.

If the requirement is primarily application and Kubernetes logs, I would start with Fluent Bit. I wouldn't introduce Firehose unless managed delivery solves a specific problem.

If we are building a unified observability platform, I would evaluate Grafana Alloy and OpenTelemetry Collector first.

Alloy would be a strong candidate if we're already invested in Grafana, Loki, Tempo, or Prometheus.

OpenTelemetry Collector would be my preference to evaluate when vendor neutrality, extensibility, and standardizing telemetry across services are the main priorities.

If AWS-managed delivery is important, Firehose becomes relevant, particularly for S3-centric data pipelines.

There may also be situations where we combine these technologies. Fluent Bit could collect logs at the edge while an OpenTelemetry Collector handles centralized processing.

But I would only introduce that separation when it solves a genuine scaling, reliability, or operational problem.

The engineering leadership perspective

Architecture complexity rarely comes from one bad decision. It usually accumulates through several individually reasonable ones.

We add a collector, then a delivery service, then another transformation layer. Eventually, we have multiple components doing overlapping work.

Every additional component brings another dependency, another failure point, and another system the engineering team must understand.

That does not mean fewer components are always better. Sometimes an additional layer is exactly what we need for reliability or scalability.

But I believe every component should earn its place.

My approach is to start with the simplest architecture that meets our requirements, measure its limitations, and introduce additional layers only when there is a clear reason.

Whether we choose Fluent Bit, Grafana Alloy, OpenTelemetry Collector, or AWS Firehose matters less than understanding why we made that choice.

At the end of the day, great architecture is not about building the most sophisticated architecture. It is about building one that our teams can operate reliably, scale confidently, and maintain without unnecessary complexity.

Top comments (0)